Remembering Graham Staines: A Story of Forgiveness, and a Flawed Judgment

In the wee hours of January 23, 1999, a senseless act of brutality shook the very foundations of humanity, as Graham Staines and his two innocent children, Philip and Timothy, were callously incinerated in their station wagon in Orissa's Keonjhar district. He had dedicated his life to caring for leprosy patients in Odisha's rural areas. 

The haunting memories of that ill-fated night continue to sear the collective conscience of the nation, serving as a heart-wrenching testament to the ravages of unbridled hate and intolerance.

In a remarkable display of Christian love, Gladys Staines, the wife of Graham Staines, exemplified the true spirit of her faith by forgiving the murderers of her husband and sons. Despite the unimaginable trauma and grief she endured, Gladys chose to respond with love and mercy, rather than hatred and vengeance. Her act of forgiveness was a powerful testament to the transformative power of Christian faith and forgiveness.

However, the judgment delivered by Justice P. Sathasivam in 2011 sparked controversy and outrage. The original observation made by the judge, who later became the chief justice of India, suggested that the brutal murder was intended to "teach a lesson" to Graham Staines about his religious activities.

This remark was widely criticized for its insensitive and troubling implications.

The recall of the observation and the insertion of a new paragraph emphasizing the importance of respecting individuals' religious beliefs were welcome moves.

Justice P. Sathasivam, who commuted the death sentence of Dara Singh to life imprisonment, was appointed the Governor of Kerala by the Modi government in 2014.

Graham's legacy continues to inspire countless individuals and organizations working towards the betterment of humanity.

By Fr Suresh Mathew